Register below, select BRATS2013 as the research unit
How to join BRATS 2013 if you are already registered (e.g. in BRATS2012):
Navigate to MySMIR, scroll to "Group Membership" apply for a new Membership by selecting BRATS2013
More information can be found at
NCI-MICCAI 2013 Grand Challenges in Image Segmentation
Brain tumor image data used in this article were obtained from the MICCAI 2013 Challenge on Multimodal Brain Tumor Segmentation. The challenge database contain fully anonymized images from the Cancer Imaging Atlas Archive and the BRATS 2012 challenge.
The outcome of the BRATS2012 and BRATS2013 challenges has been summarized in the following publication. Authors using the BRATS dataset are kindly requested to cite this work:
BRATS 2012 & 2013: Contributed algorithmic segmentations of the test data: Static Results and Testdata Download
Please register to receive an email with your login link and activate your account.
10 patient datasets for download:
You need to log in to download the challenge data!
25 patient datasets for download:
You need to log in to download the leaderboard data!
30 patient datasets and 50 synthetic datasets including ground truths are available for download:
You need to log in to download the training data!
You need to log in to download the observer ground truth data!
All images are stored as signed 16-bit integers, but only positive values are used. The manual segmentations (Truth) of the patient images have the following four different labels:
1 for necrosis 2 for edema 3 for non-enhancing tumor 4 for enhancing tumor 0 for everything else
here are 3 requirements for the successfull upload and validation of your segmentation:
replace the ### with the ID of the corresponding Flair MR images. This allows the system to relate your segmentation to the correct training truth. Download an example list for the training data and leaderboard data and challenge data.
Filename of the High Grade Flair 0001 MR: VSD.Brain.XX.O.MR_Flair.687.mha The VSD-Id would be 687 Filename of your segmentation: VSD.Seg_HG_001.687.mha
Filename of the Low Grade 011 Flair MR: VSD.Brain.XX.O.MR_Flair.835.mha The VSD-Id would be 835 Filename of your segmentation: VSD.Seg_LG_011.835.mha
The evaluation is done for 3 different tumor sub-compartements:
Position | Dice | Positive Predictive Value | Sensitivity | Complete tumor Rank | Tumor core Rank | Enhancing tumor Rank | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
complete | core | enhancing | complete | core | enhancing | complete | core | enhancing | |||||
1 | 0.89 (1) | 0.82 (4) | 0.76 (3) | 0.83 (37) | 0.83 (20) | 0.79 (10) | 0.96 (1) | 0.87 (3) | 0.76 (24) | 13.00 | 9.00 | 12.33 | |
2 | 0.88 (5) | 0.83 (2) | 0.77 (2) | 0.88 (14) | 0.87 (7) | 0.74 (26) | 0.89 (33) | 0.83 (10) | 0.81 (11) | 17.33 | 6.33 | 13.00 | |
3 | 0.87 (12) | 0.84 (1) | 0.77 (1) | 0.88 (16) | 0.87 (6) | 0.76 (18) | 0.88 (38) | 0.82 (12) | 0.80 (13) | 22.00 | 6.33 | 10.67 | |
4 | 0.88 (4) | 0.81 (10) | 0.76 (5) | 0.89 (9) | 0.81 (28) | 0.71 (38) | 0.88 (36) | 0.83 (9) | 0.83 (5) | 16.33 | 15.67 | 16.00 | |
5 | 0.88 (9) | 0.81 (8) | 0.75 (8) | 0.84 (33) | 0.79 (36) | 0.72 (34) | 0.92 (16) | 0.88 (1) | 0.80 (14) | 19.33 | 15.00 | 18.67 | |
6 | 0.89 (2) | 0.80 (12) | 0.74 (13) | 0.86 (19) | 0.86 (13) | 0.78 (13) | 0.92 (18) | 0.76 (33) | 0.73 (36) | 13.00 | 19.33 | 20.67 | |
7 | 0.87 (15) | 0.82 (6) | 0.76 (4) | 0.82 (39) | 0.81 (27) | 0.67 (50) | 0.93 (13) | 0.86 (5) | 0.90 (1) | 22.33 | 12.67 | 18.33 | |
8 | 0.87 (17) | 0.82 (5) | 0.75 (7) | 0.84 (31) | 0.85 (17) | 0.70 (43) | 0.91 (21) | 0.82 (14) | 0.82 (8) | 23.00 | 12.00 | 19.33 | |
9 | 0.87 (11) | 0.80 (11) | 0.76 (6) | 0.91 (5) | 0.88 (4) | 0.77 (16) | 0.83 (54) | 0.77 (31) | 0.76 (26) | 23.33 | 15.33 | 16.00 | |
10 | 0.88 (3) | 0.80 (13) | 0.73 (26) | 0.88 (11) | 0.87 (8) | 0.80 (5) | 0.89 (30) | 0.77 (30) | 0.70 (44) | 14.67 | 17.00 | 25.00 | |
11 | 0.88 (7) | 0.83 (3) | 0.72 (28) | 0.92 (4) | 0.90 (2) | 0.74 (27) | 0.84 (50) | 0.78 (25) | 0.72 (40) | 20.33 | 10.00 | 31.67 | |
12 | 0.87 (10) | 0.78 (15) | 0.71 (33) | 0.82 (40) | 0.80 (31) | 0.83 (1) | 0.95 (3) | 0.80 (19) | 0.67 (52) | 17.67 | 21.67 | 28.67 | |
13 | 0.86 (24) | 0.78 (19) | 0.74 (10) | 0.81 (43) | 0.77 (40) | 0.79 (11) | 0.93 (11) | 0.82 (15) | 0.73 (32) | 26.00 | 24.67 | 17.67 | |
14 | 0.88 (8) | 0.77 (24) | 0.72 (27) | 0.83 (34) | 0.77 (42) | 0.81 (3) | 0.93 (6) | 0.82 (13) | 0.69 (49) | 16.00 | 26.33 | 26.33 | |
15 | 0.87 (20) | 0.78 (18) | 0.74 (11) | 0.85 (25) | 0.74 (51) | 0.69 (45) | 0.89 (28) | 0.88 (2) | 0.83 (6) | 24.33 | 23.67 | 20.67 | |
16 | 0.88 (6) | 0.75 (34) | 0.74 (12) | 0.88 (12) | 0.77 (41) | 0.78 (12) | 0.88 (35) | 0.78 (27) | 0.72 (38) | 17.67 | 34.00 | 20.67 | |
17 | 0.85 (30) | 0.78 (14) | 0.73 (18) | 0.80 (47) | 0.86 (10) | 0.76 (20) | 0.93 (10) | 0.74 (41) | 0.74 (30) | 29.00 | 21.67 | 22.67 | |
18 | 0.87 (16) | 0.82 (7) | 0.70 (40) | 0.90 (6) | 0.82 (23) | 0.73 (30) | 0.85 (48) | 0.87 (4) | 0.69 (48) | 23.33 | 11.33 | 39.33 | |
19 | 0.85 (31) | 0.78 (16) | 0.75 (9) | 0.88 (15) | 0.86 (12) | 0.72 (35) | 0.84 (51) | 0.73 (43) | 0.80 (12) | 32.33 | 23.67 | 18.67 | |
20 | 0.87 (14) | 0.76 (30) | 0.73 (16) | 0.85 (23) | 0.76 (43) | 0.71 (39) | 0.89 (31) | 0.81 (16) | 0.77 (18) | 22.67 | 29.67 | 24.33 | |
21 | 0.87 (13) | 0.78 (17) | 0.70 (36) | 0.89 (7) | 0.83 (22) | 0.75 (23) | 0.86 (45) | 0.78 (24) | 0.70 (46) | 21.67 | 21.00 | 35.00 | |
22 | 0.87 (18) | 0.77 (21) | 0.73 (24) | 0.84 (28) | 0.79 (35) | 0.73 (28) | 0.90 (26) | 0.78 (26) | 0.75 (27) | 24.00 | 27.33 | 26.33 | |
23 | 0.85 (29) | 0.76 (27) | 0.73 (17) | 0.80 (46) | 0.85 (14) | 0.77 (14) | 0.93 (9) | 0.72 (47) | 0.73 (34) | 28.00 | 29.33 | 21.67 | |
24 | 0.85 (34) | 0.77 (23) | 0.73 (21) | 0.79 (50) | 0.83 (21) | 0.77 (15) | 0.93 (5) | 0.74 (40) | 0.73 (33) | 29.67 | 28.00 | 23.00 | |
25 | 0.85 (40) | 0.77 (26) | 0.73 (19) | 0.79 (51) | 0.85 (15) | 0.77 (17) | 0.93 (7) | 0.72 (45) | 0.74 (31) | 32.67 | 28.67 | 22.33 | |
26 | 0.87 (19) | 0.77 (25) | 0.72 (29) | 0.84 (27) | 0.80 (33) | 0.71 (37) | 0.89 (29) | 0.76 (34) | 0.77 (21) | 25.00 | 30.67 | 29.00 | |
27 | 0.86 (21) | 0.75 (35) | 0.73 (25) | 0.82 (41) | 0.75 (47) | 0.79 (7) | 0.92 (14) | 0.79 (23) | 0.70 (43) | 25.33 | 35.00 | 25.00 | |
28 | 0.86 (28) | 0.76 (28) | 0.73 (20) | 0.81 (42) | 0.84 (18) | 0.73 (31) | 0.91 (20) | 0.72 (48) | 0.77 (22) | 30.00 | 31.33 | 24.33 | |
29 | 0.86 (22) | 0.73 (44) | 0.74 (14) | 0.83 (36) | 0.70 (57) | 0.76 (21) | 0.91 (19) | 0.80 (17) | 0.75 (29) | 25.67 | 39.33 | 21.33 | |
30 | 0.85 (33) | 0.78 (20) | 0.73 (23) | 0.95 (1) | 0.81 (25) | 0.70 (42) | 0.78 (61) | 0.76 (36) | 0.77 (20) | 31.67 | 27.00 | 28.33 | |
31 | 0.86 (26) | 0.74 (40) | 0.73 (15) | 0.83 (35) | 0.74 (49) | 0.68 (49) | 0.90 (24) | 0.78 (28) | 0.81 (9) | 28.33 | 39.00 | 24.33 | |
32 | 0.85 (41) | 0.81 (9) | 0.70 (38) | 0.84 (29) | 0.86 (11) | 0.70 (40) | 0.86 (44) | 0.78 (29) | 0.70 (42) | 38.00 | 16.33 | 40.00 | |
33 | 0.85 (37) | 0.73 (43) | 0.73 (22) | 0.80 (48) | 0.67 (61) | 0.66 (52) | 0.93 (12) | 0.85 (6) | 0.84 (4) | 32.33 | 36.67 | 26.00 | |
34 | 0.85 (32) | 0.76 (29) | 0.72 (32) | 0.84 (30) | 0.81 (26) | 0.75 (24) | 0.87 (40) | 0.76 (35) | 0.71 (41) | 34.00 | 30.00 | 32.33 | |
35 | 0.83 (47) | 0.75 (33) | 0.72 (31) | 0.76 (58) | 0.72 (55) | 0.65 (56) | 0.92 (17) | 0.85 (7) | 0.85 (3) | 40.67 | 31.67 | 30.00 | |
36 | 0.85 (35) | 0.75 (37) | 0.72 (30) | 0.81 (44) | 0.74 (50) | 0.69 (46) | 0.90 (25) | 0.79 (21) | 0.76 (25) | 34.67 | 36.00 | 33.67 | |
37 | 0.86 (27) | 0.73 (45) | 0.71 (34) | 0.81 (45) | 0.75 (45) | 0.75 (22) | 0.92 (15) | 0.73 (44) | 0.70 (45) | 29.00 | 44.67 | 33.67 | |
38 | 0.84 (44) | 0.75 (36) | 0.70 (35) | 0.85 (24) | 0.81 (29) | 0.67 (51) | 0.83 (53) | 0.74 (39) | 0.78 (16) | 40.33 | 34.67 | 34.00 | |
39 | 0.83 (48) | 0.76 (31) | 0.70 (37) | 0.77 (54) | 0.80 (30) | 0.73 (32) | 0.90 (22) | 0.73 (42) | 0.73 (35) | 41.33 | 34.33 | 34.67 | |
40 | 0.86 (23) | 0.71 (47) | 0.62 (60) | 0.88 (17) | 0.84 (19) | 0.80 (6) | 0.85 (46) | 0.66 (57) | 0.56 (61) | 28.67 | 41.00 | 42.33 | |
41 | 0.78 (56) | 0.75 (32) | 0.68 (46) | 0.67 (64) | 0.73 (53) | 0.59 (63) | 0.95 (2) | 0.80 (18) | 0.82 (7) | 40.67 | 34.33 | 38.67 | |
42 | 0.83 (46) | 0.74 (42) | 0.67 (49) | 0.89 (8) | 0.89 (3) | 0.76 (19) | 0.79 (59) | 0.65 (58) | 0.63 (59) | 37.67 | 34.33 | 42.33 | |
43 | 0.85 (38) | 0.74 (41) | 0.69 (44) | 0.87 (18) | 0.74 (52) | 0.63 (58) | 0.84 (52) | 0.75 (38) | 0.77 (19) | 36.00 | 43.67 | 40.33 | |
44 | 0.84 (45) | 0.72 (46) | 0.70 (39) | 0.77 (55) | 0.75 (46) | 0.68 (48) | 0.93 (8) | 0.71 (51) | 0.77 (23) | 36.00 | 47.67 | 36.67 | |
45 | 0.81 (53) | 0.75 (38) | 0.68 (45) | 0.79 (49) | 0.86 (9) | 0.79 (8) | 0.85 (49) | 0.69 (54) | 0.65 (57) | 50.33 | 33.67 | 36.67 | |
46 | 0.86 (25) | 0.69 (53) | 0.69 (41) | 0.88 (13) | 0.72 (56) | 0.71 (36) | 0.85 (47) | 0.72 (50) | 0.69 (50) | 28.33 | 53.00 | 42.33 | |
47 | 0.82 (50) | 0.71 (49) | 0.69 (43) | 0.78 (52) | 0.68 (60) | 0.62 (59) | 0.89 (34) | 0.79 (20) | 0.81 (10) | 45.33 | 43.00 | 37.33 | |
48 | 0.81 (52) | 0.68 (56) | 0.68 (47) | 0.86 (20) | 0.87 (5) | 0.74 (25) | 0.79 (58) | 0.58 (64) | 0.66 (53) | 43.33 | 41.67 | 41.67 | |
49 | 0.78 (55) | 0.71 (48) | 0.64 (58) | 0.92 (3) | 0.80 (34) | 0.79 (9) | 0.72 (66) | 0.68 (55) | 0.58 (60) | 41.33 | 45.67 | 42.33 | |
50 | 0.84 (43) | 0.68 (54) | 0.65 (56) | 0.92 (2) | 0.85 (16) | 0.70 (44) | 0.78 (60) | 0.61 (61) | 0.66 (55) | 35.00 | 43.67 | 51.67 | |
51 | 0.83 (49) | 0.70 (51) | 0.61 (61) | 0.86 (21) | 0.80 (32) | 0.82 (2) | 0.81 (57) | 0.66 (56) | 0.56 (62) | 42.33 | 46.33 | 41.67 | |
52 | 0.84 (42) | 0.68 (57) | 0.65 (54) | 0.88 (10) | 0.63 (63) | 0.68 (47) | 0.81 (56) | 0.82 (11) | 0.66 (54) | 36.00 | 43.67 | 51.67 | |
53 | 0.77 (57) | 0.74 (39) | 0.65 (52) | 0.66 (66) | 0.79 (37) | 0.62 (60) | 0.94 (4) | 0.72 (46) | 0.72 (37) | 42.33 | 40.67 | 49.67 | |
54 | 0.74 (62) | 0.54 (65) | 0.56 (63) | 0.85 (22) | 0.92 (1) | 0.81 (4) | 0.73 (63) | 0.46 (67) | 0.51 (65) | 49.00 | 44.33 | 44.00 | |
55 | 0.74 (63) | 0.68 (55) | 0.58 (62) | 0.68 (63) | 0.70 (59) | 0.49 (66) | 0.90 (27) | 0.79 (22) | 0.86 (2) | 51.00 | 45.33 | 43.33 | |
56 | 0.85 (36) | 0.58 (63) | 0.65 (53) | 0.83 (38) | 0.58 (64) | 0.58 (64) | 0.88 (37) | 0.70 (52) | 0.79 (15) | 37.00 | 59.67 | 44.00 | |
57 | 0.75 (61) | 0.70 (50) | 0.67 (50) | 0.66 (67) | 0.67 (62) | 0.61 (61) | 0.90 (23) | 0.76 (32) | 0.78 (17) | 50.33 | 48.00 | 42.67 | |
58 | 0.82 (51) | 0.77 (22) | 0.00 (69) | 0.76 (57) | 0.74 (48) | 0.00 (69) | 0.89 (32) | 0.84 (8) | 0.00 (69) | 46.67 | 26.00 | 69.00 | |
59 | 0.85 (39) | 0.68 (58) | 0.65 (55) | 0.84 (32) | 0.76 (44) | 0.66 (53) | 0.87 (41) | 0.63 (60) | 0.69 (51) | 37.33 | 54.00 | 53.00 | |
60 | 0.76 (59) | 0.69 (52) | 0.69 (42) | 0.69 (61) | 0.70 (58) | 0.65 (55) | 0.87 (42) | 0.76 (37) | 0.75 (28) | 54.00 | 49.00 | 41.67 | |
61 | 0.77 (58) | 0.64 (60) | 0.64 (57) | 0.85 (26) | 0.73 (54) | 0.73 (29) | 0.72 (64) | 0.59 (63) | 0.64 (58) | 49.33 | 59.00 | 48.00 | |
62 | 0.79 (54) | 0.62 (61) | 0.48 (66) | 0.78 (53) | 0.82 (24) | 0.72 (33) | 0.82 (55) | 0.55 (65) | 0.42 (66) | 54.00 | 50.00 | 55.00 | |
63 | 0.72 (64) | 0.66 (59) | 0.67 (48) | 0.77 (56) | 0.77 (38) | 0.70 (41) | 0.72 (65) | 0.60 (62) | 0.70 (47) | 61.67 | 53.00 | 45.33 | |
64 | 0.70 (66) | 0.57 (64) | 0.65 (51) | 0.68 (62) | 0.53 (65) | 0.65 (57) | 0.74 (62) | 0.65 (59) | 0.72 (39) | 63.33 | 62.67 | 49.00 | |
65 | 0.69 (67) | 0.59 (62) | 0.62 (59) | 0.71 (60) | 0.77 (39) | 0.65 (54) | 0.69 (67) | 0.49 (66) | 0.65 (56) | 64.67 | 55.67 | 56.33 | |
66 | 0.76 (60) | 0.52 (66) | 0.54 (64) | 0.71 (59) | 0.42 (66) | 0.61 (62) | 0.87 (43) | 0.72 (49) | 0.53 (64) | 54.00 | 60.33 | 63.33 | |
67 | 0.71 (65) | 0.46 (67) | 0.52 (65) | 0.66 (65) | 0.38 (67) | 0.58 (65) | 0.87 (39) | 0.70 (53) | 0.55 (63) | 56.33 | 62.33 | 64.33 | |
68 | 0.09 (68) | 0.09 (68) | 0.08 (67) | 0.09 (68) | 0.09 (68) | 0.08 (67) | 0.08 (69) | 0.09 (68) | 0.09 (67) | 68.33 | 68.00 | 67.00 | |
69 | 0.06 (69) | 0.00 (69) | 0.00 (68) | 0.06 (69) | 0.01 (69) | 0.00 (68) | 0.13 (68) | 0.00 (69) | 0.00 (68) | 68.67 | 69.00 | 68.00 |
Position | Dice | Positive Predictive Value | Sensitivity | Complete tumor Rank | Tumor core Rank | Enhancing tumor Rank | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
complete | core | enhancing | complete | core | enhancing | complete | core | enhancing | |||||
1 | 0.84 (6) | 0.72 (5) | 0.62 (1) | 0.85 (7) | 0.82 (4) | 0.60 (7) | 0.86 (18) | 0.76 (10) | 0.68 (8) | 10.33 | 6.33 | 5.33 | |
2 | 0.84 (5) | 0.71 (8) | 0.60 (6) | 0.83 (9) | 0.72 (15) | 0.60 (10) | 0.90 (7) | 0.80 (5) | 0.71 (2) | 7.00 | 9.33 | 6.00 | |
3 | 0.86 (2) | 0.79 (1) | 0.59 (11) | 0.88 (2) | 0.84 (3) | 0.60 (8) | 0.86 (20) | 0.81 (4) | 0.63 (22) | 8.00 | 2.67 | 13.67 | |
4 | 0.83 (9) | 0.73 (3) | 0.62 (2) | 0.91 (1) | 0.76 (8) | 0.64 (2) | 0.78 (38) | 0.77 (7) | 0.68 (9) | 16.00 | 6.00 | 4.33 | |
5 | 0.87 (1) | 0.70 (10) | 0.61 (3) | 0.86 (5) | 0.62 (31) | 0.60 (9) | 0.91 (5) | 0.93 (1) | 0.65 (16) | 3.67 | 14.00 | 9.33 | |
6 | 0.86 (3) | 0.70 (9) | 0.60 (7) | 0.82 (11) | 0.77 (7) | 0.57 (12) | 0.91 (4) | 0.68 (23) | 0.68 (10) | 6.00 | 13.00 | 9.67 | |
7 | 0.78 (20) | 0.70 (11) | 0.61 (4) | 0.72 (24) | 0.71 (16) | 0.57 (13) | 0.90 (6) | 0.76 (8) | 0.71 (3) | 16.67 | 11.67 | 6.67 | |
8 | 0.84 (7) | 0.68 (12) | 0.59 (9) | 0.86 (4) | 0.86 (1) | 0.61 (6) | 0.84 (24) | 0.65 (34) | 0.68 (12) | 11.67 | 15.67 | 9.00 | |
9 | 0.84 (4) | 0.79 (2) | 0.50 (34) | 0.79 (16) | 0.85 (2) | 0.42 (42) | 0.94 (2) | 0.79 (6) | 0.70 (5) | 7.33 | 3.33 | 27.00 | |
10 | 0.83 (10) | 0.73 (4) | 0.55 (20) | 0.77 (21) | 0.67 (23) | 0.46 (37) | 0.94 (1) | 0.89 (2) | 0.78 (1) | 10.67 | 9.67 | 19.33 | |
11 | 0.82 (12) | 0.66 (17) | 0.60 (5) | 0.82 (10) | 0.77 (6) | 0.61 (5) | 0.87 (16) | 0.66 (31) | 0.63 (23) | 12.67 | 18.00 | 11.00 | |
12 | 0.82 (13) | 0.67 (15) | 0.59 (10) | 0.81 (12) | 0.68 (18) | 0.56 (17) | 0.87 (13) | 0.70 (17) | 0.65 (17) | 12.67 | 16.67 | 14.67 | |
13 | 0.83 (11) | 0.71 (7) | 0.54 (24) | 0.85 (6) | 0.73 (13) | 0.59 (11) | 0.84 (25) | 0.82 (3) | 0.58 (32) | 14.00 | 7.67 | 22.33 | |
14 | 0.83 (8) | 0.67 (14) | 0.57 (15) | 0.88 (3) | 0.75 (9) | 0.65 (1) | 0.83 (29) | 0.69 (20) | 0.57 (35) | 13.33 | 14.33 | 17.00 | |
15 | 0.79 (17) | 0.67 (16) | 0.60 (8) | 0.80 (13) | 0.74 (11) | 0.56 (16) | 0.81 (33) | 0.68 (24) | 0.70 (4) | 21.00 | 17.00 | 9.33 | |
16 | 0.78 (21) | 0.64 (20) | 0.57 (16) | 0.71 (26) | 0.66 (25) | 0.63 (4) | 0.93 (3) | 0.73 (12) | 0.59 (31) | 16.67 | 19.00 | 17.00 | |
17 | 0.79 (16) | 0.67 (13) | 0.54 (22) | 0.77 (20) | 0.75 (10) | 0.55 (20) | 0.86 (19) | 0.70 (16) | 0.62 (25) | 18.33 | 13.00 | 22.33 | |
18 | 0.79 (18) | 0.71 (6) | 0.50 (33) | 0.73 (23) | 0.77 (5) | 0.50 (29) | 0.88 (12) | 0.76 (9) | 0.60 (28) | 17.67 | 6.67 | 30.00 | |
19 | 0.79 (15) | 0.65 (19) | 0.53 (30) | 0.83 (8) | 0.70 (17) | 0.51 (27) | 0.81 (34) | 0.73 (11) | 0.66 (14) | 19.00 | 15.67 | 23.67 | |
20 | 0.75 (26) | 0.62 (24) | 0.57 (13) | 0.69 (30) | 0.68 (20) | 0.53 (22) | 0.89 (8) | 0.64 (36) | 0.69 (7) | 21.33 | 26.67 | 14.00 | |
21 | 0.76 (22) | 0.61 (27) | 0.55 (19) | 0.74 (22) | 0.68 (19) | 0.64 (3) | 0.86 (17) | 0.67 (28) | 0.56 (36) | 20.33 | 24.67 | 19.33 | |
22 | 0.78 (19) | 0.66 (18) | 0.54 (25) | 0.77 (19) | 0.74 (12) | 0.52 (24) | 0.84 (26) | 0.68 (25) | 0.62 (26) | 21.33 | 18.33 | 25.00 | |
23 | 0.76 (24) | 0.64 (21) | 0.56 (17) | 0.69 (29) | 0.67 (22) | 0.55 (18) | 0.89 (9) | 0.67 (27) | 0.62 (27) | 20.67 | 23.33 | 20.67 | |
24 | 0.73 (28) | 0.64 (22) | 0.57 (12) | 0.71 (27) | 0.66 (24) | 0.53 (23) | 0.82 (30) | 0.68 (26) | 0.68 (11) | 28.33 | 24.00 | 15.33 | |
25 | 0.68 (37) | 0.63 (23) | 0.57 (14) | 0.61 (42) | 0.65 (27) | 0.56 (15) | 0.87 (14) | 0.69 (21) | 0.64 (21) | 31.00 | 23.67 | 16.67 | |
26 | 0.71 (33) | 0.61 (26) | 0.53 (31) | 0.63 (39) | 0.58 (34) | 0.50 (30) | 0.89 (10) | 0.72 (13) | 0.64 (19) | 27.33 | 24.33 | 26.67 | |
27 | 0.72 (31) | 0.60 (29) | 0.53 (32) | 0.65 (34) | 0.62 (29) | 0.48 (33) | 0.88 (11) | 0.69 (19) | 0.64 (18) | 25.33 | 25.67 | 27.67 | |
28 | 0.76 (23) | 0.60 (30) | 0.53 (28) | 0.78 (17) | 0.62 (30) | 0.57 (14) | 0.79 (36) | 0.67 (29) | 0.55 (37) | 25.33 | 29.67 | 26.33 | |
29 | 0.72 (30) | 0.58 (33) | 0.55 (21) | 0.69 (31) | 0.63 (28) | 0.52 (25) | 0.85 (21) | 0.66 (32) | 0.63 (24) | 27.33 | 31.00 | 23.33 | |
30 | 0.73 (29) | 0.62 (25) | 0.54 (27) | 0.72 (25) | 0.65 (26) | 0.49 (31) | 0.80 (35) | 0.65 (33) | 0.66 (15) | 29.67 | 28.00 | 24.33 | |
31 | 0.69 (35) | 0.59 (31) | 0.56 (18) | 0.66 (33) | 0.67 (21) | 0.53 (21) | 0.76 (41) | 0.56 (40) | 0.66 (13) | 36.33 | 30.67 | 17.33 | |
32 | 0.69 (36) | 0.58 (32) | 0.54 (23) | 0.64 (36) | 0.54 (40) | 0.51 (28) | 0.82 (31) | 0.72 (15) | 0.64 (20) | 34.33 | 29.00 | 23.67 | |
33 | 0.80 (14) | 0.54 (38) | 0.46 (39) | 0.78 (18) | 0.49 (43) | 0.47 (34) | 0.85 (22) | 0.70 (18) | 0.53 (39) | 18.00 | 33.00 | 37.33 | |
34 | 0.70 (34) | 0.57 (34) | 0.54 (26) | 0.65 (35) | 0.55 (39) | 0.52 (26) | 0.87 (15) | 0.67 (30) | 0.60 (29) | 28.00 | 34.33 | 27.00 | |
35 | 0.75 (25) | 0.61 (28) | 0.46 (40) | 0.79 (15) | 0.60 (32) | 0.43 (41) | 0.78 (37) | 0.72 (14) | 0.52 (40) | 25.67 | 24.67 | 40.33 | |
36 | 0.72 (32) | 0.55 (37) | 0.49 (35) | 0.67 (32) | 0.53 (41) | 0.46 (36) | 0.83 (28) | 0.68 (22) | 0.60 (30) | 30.67 | 33.33 | 33.67 | |
37 | 0.65 (41) | 0.49 (42) | 0.43 (42) | 0.80 (14) | 0.73 (14) | 0.55 (19) | 0.59 (45) | 0.45 (43) | 0.40 (46) | 33.33 | 33.00 | 35.67 | |
38 | 0.66 (40) | 0.54 (39) | 0.53 (29) | 0.60 (43) | 0.57 (35) | 0.46 (35) | 0.76 (40) | 0.58 (39) | 0.69 (6) | 41.00 | 37.67 | 23.33 | |
39 | 0.74 (27) | 0.55 (36) | 0.46 (38) | 0.71 (28) | 0.55 (38) | 0.41 (43) | 0.82 (32) | 0.64 (35) | 0.58 (33) | 29.00 | 36.33 | 38.00 | |
40 | 0.67 (38) | 0.56 (35) | 0.47 (37) | 0.62 (40) | 0.59 (33) | 0.49 (32) | 0.84 (23) | 0.60 (37) | 0.51 (41) | 33.67 | 35.00 | 36.67 | |
41 | 0.67 (39) | 0.50 (41) | 0.43 (41) | 0.63 (38) | 0.51 (42) | 0.41 (44) | 0.83 (27) | 0.60 (38) | 0.57 (34) | 34.67 | 40.33 | 39.67 | |
42 | 0.64 (42) | 0.52 (40) | 0.48 (36) | 0.64 (37) | 0.55 (37) | 0.45 (39) | 0.70 (42) | 0.56 (41) | 0.54 (38) | 40.33 | 39.33 | 37.67 | |
43 | 0.63 (43) | 0.42 (43) | 0.42 (43) | 0.61 (41) | 0.39 (46) | 0.45 (38) | 0.68 (43) | 0.48 (42) | 0.43 (44) | 42.33 | 43.67 | 41.67 | |
44 | 0.55 (45) | 0.38 (46) | 0.41 (44) | 0.59 (44) | 0.57 (36) | 0.44 (40) | 0.57 (46) | 0.33 (47) | 0.42 (45) | 45.00 | 43.00 | 43.00 | |
45 | 0.51 (46) | 0.40 (44) | 0.40 (45) | 0.47 (46) | 0.45 (44) | 0.40 (45) | 0.76 (39) | 0.43 (44) | 0.50 (42) | 43.67 | 44.00 | 44.00 | |
46 | 0.56 (44) | 0.40 (45) | 0.39 (46) | 0.54 (45) | 0.43 (45) | 0.36 (46) | 0.61 (44) | 0.41 (45) | 0.45 (43) | 44.33 | 45.00 | 45.00 | |
47 | 0.34 (48) | 0.34 (47) | 0.31 (47) | 0.30 (50) | 0.32 (50) | 0.27 (48) | 0.39 (48) | 0.37 (46) | 0.38 (47) | 48.67 | 47.67 | 47.33 | |
48 | 0.38 (47) | 0.30 (50) | 0.26 (50) | 0.41 (47) | 0.34 (48) | 0.26 (50) | 0.40 (47) | 0.32 (48) | 0.32 (48) | 47.00 | 48.67 | 49.33 | |
49 | 0.33 (50) | 0.32 (48) | 0.29 (48) | 0.35 (49) | 0.35 (47) | 0.34 (47) | 0.32 (50) | 0.30 (49) | 0.26 (50) | 49.67 | 48.00 | 48.33 | |
50 | 0.33 (49) | 0.30 (49) | 0.29 (49) | 0.30 (51) | 0.34 (49) | 0.27 (49) | 0.38 (49) | 0.28 (50) | 0.31 (49) | 49.67 | 49.33 | 49.00 | |
51 | 0.26 (51) | 0.16 (51) | 0.00 (51) | 0.38 (48) | 0.18 (51) | 0.00 (51) | 0.23 (51) | 0.21 (51) | 0.00 (51) | 50.00 | 51.00 | 51.00 | |
52 | 0.07 (52) | 0.04 (52) | 0.00 (51) | 0.07 (52) | 0.05 (52) | 0.00 (51) | 0.10 (52) | 0.07 (52) | 0.00 (51) | 52.00 | 52.00 | 51.00 |
Position | Dice | Positive Predictive Value | Sensitivity | Kappa | Complete tumor Rank | Tumor core Rank | Enhancing tumor Rank | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
complete | core | enhancing | complete | core | enhancing | complete | core | enhancing | |||||
1 | 0.92 (1) | 0.91 (2) | 0.68 (1) | 0.97 (1) | 0.95 (1) | 0.70 (1) | 0.89 (7) | 0.88 (4) | 0.66 (3) | 1.00 (1) | 2.50 | 2.25 | 7.50 |
2 | 0.92 (2) | 0.93 (1) | 0.63 (2) | 0.86 (13) | 0.92 (2) | 0.63 (7) | 0.98 (1) | 0.94 (1) | 0.64 (4) | 1.00 (3) | 4.75 | 1.25 | 9.75 |
3 | 0.87 (7) | 0.87 (4) | 0.61 (3) | 0.78 (22) | 0.83 (8) | 0.57 (14) | 0.98 (2) | 0.93 (2) | 0.66 (2) | 1.00 (8) | 9.75 | 4.25 | 5.00 |
4 | 0.87 (5) | 0.73 (8) | 0.58 (4) | 0.93 (3) | 0.86 (7) | 0.62 (9) | 0.84 (12) | 0.69 (12) | 0.61 (6) | 1.00 (5) | 6.25 | 9.25 | 5.25 |
5 | 0.88 (4) | 0.76 (6) | 0.55 (9) | 0.88 (9) | 0.80 (11) | 0.65 (5) | 0.89 (6) | 0.79 (7) | 0.53 (10) | 1.00 (4) | 5.75 | 7.50 | 10.00 |
6 | 0.91 (3) | 0.88 (3) | 0.45 (25) | 0.91 (6) | 0.88 (4) | 0.37 (29) | 0.92 (4) | 0.89 (3) | 0.68 (1) | 1.00 (2) | 3.75 | 3.50 | 16.75 |
7 | 0.84 (12) | 0.71 (9) | 0.56 (7) | 0.92 (4) | 0.78 (13) | 0.64 (6) | 0.78 (24) | 0.69 (11) | 0.51 (11) | 1.00 (7) | 11.75 | 9.50 | 6.75 |
8 | 0.86 (8) | 0.75 (7) | 0.55 (10) | 0.88 (10) | 0.86 (6) | 0.65 (3) | 0.86 (10) | 0.72 (9) | 0.50 (15) | 1.00 (10) | 9.50 | 7.75 | 11.75 |
9 | 0.86 (9) | 0.70 (10) | 0.54 (11) | 0.94 (2) | 0.88 (3) | 0.65 (4) | 0.81 (20) | 0.66 (19) | 0.54 (8) | 1.00 (6) | 9.25 | 10.75 | 11.50 |
10 | 0.87 (6) | 0.79 (5) | 0.53 (12) | 0.92 (5) | 0.82 (10) | 0.56 (15) | 0.83 (14) | 0.80 (6) | 0.54 (9) | 1.00 (9) | 8.50 | 7.00 | 16.25 |
11 | 0.83 (14) | 0.67 (13) | 0.55 (8) | 0.90 (8) | 0.77 (14) | 0.66 (2) | 0.80 (22) | 0.69 (14) | 0.51 (12) | 1.00 (12) | 14.00 | 13.50 | 10.50 |
12 | 0.79 (20) | 0.68 (12) | 0.57 (6) | 0.81 (20) | 0.75 (16) | 0.54 (18) | 0.79 (23) | 0.67 (16) | 0.63 (5) | 1.00 (15) | 19.50 | 13.00 | 8.50 |
13 | 0.79 (18) | 0.62 (20) | 0.57 (5) | 0.82 (19) | 0.80 (12) | 0.60 (10) | 0.80 (21) | 0.57 (23) | 0.57 (7) | 1.00 (17) | 18.75 | 17.50 | 6.50 |
14 | 0.83 (15) | 0.66 (14) | 0.52 (14) | 0.85 (15) | 0.74 (17) | 0.59 (13) | 0.83 (15) | 0.66 (17) | 0.50 (16) | 1.00 (14) | 14.75 | 15.50 | 15.00 |
15 | 0.85 (10) | 0.58 (22) | 0.48 (20) | 0.88 (11) | 0.76 (15) | 0.60 (12) | 0.85 (11) | 0.53 (27) | 0.46 (22) | 1.00 (11) | 10.75 | 20.50 | 15.00 |
16 | 0.83 (13) | 0.54 (24) | 0.48 (18) | 0.84 (17) | 0.47 (27) | 0.51 (23) | 0.86 (9) | 0.77 (8) | 0.51 (13) | 1.00 (16) | 13.75 | 21.00 | 15.50 |
17 | 0.81 (16) | 0.69 (11) | 0.49 (16) | 0.78 (24) | 0.63 (22) | 0.54 (17) | 0.89 (5) | 0.85 (5) | 0.46 (21) | 0.99 (21) | 16.50 | 15.00 | 18.75 |
18 | 0.78 (21) | 0.66 (16) | 0.46 (23) | 0.66 (27) | 0.87 (5) | 0.62 (8) | 0.97 (3) | 0.56 (24) | 0.40 (28) | 0.99 (23) | 18.50 | 14.25 | 18.50 |
19 | 0.79 (19) | 0.64 (18) | 0.49 (15) | 0.79 (21) | 0.74 (18) | 0.54 (19) | 0.82 (16) | 0.61 (20) | 0.49 (18) | 0.99 (20) | 19.00 | 18.00 | 16.50 |
20 | 0.79 (17) | 0.66 (15) | 0.48 (17) | 0.90 (7) | 0.73 (19) | 0.52 (22) | 0.73 (27) | 0.66 (18) | 0.49 (19) | 1.00 (19) | 17.50 | 17.25 | 19.00 |
21 | 0.77 (22) | 0.63 (19) | 0.47 (21) | 0.84 (16) | 0.67 (21) | 0.56 (16) | 0.75 (26) | 0.69 (10) | 0.45 (24) | 1.00 (18) | 20.50 | 17.75 | 17.00 |
22 | 0.84 (11) | 0.65 (17) | 0.44 (26) | 0.86 (12) | 0.70 (20) | 0.51 (24) | 0.84 (13) | 0.69 (15) | 0.42 (27) | 1.00 (13) | 12.25 | 18.00 | 26.25 |
23 | 0.68 (27) | 0.62 (21) | 0.52 (13) | 0.78 (23) | 0.83 (9) | 0.60 (11) | 0.62 (29) | 0.53 (26) | 0.50 (14) | 0.99 (22) | 25.25 | 18.75 | 16.25 |
24 | 0.73 (23) | 0.53 (25) | 0.35 (29) | 0.85 (14) | 0.62 (23) | 0.52 (21) | 0.69 (28) | 0.55 (25) | 0.32 (33) | 0.99 (24) | 22.25 | 24.00 | 23.25 |
25 | 0.73 (24) | 0.46 (27) | 0.33 (30) | 0.69 (26) | 0.46 (29) | 0.37 (30) | 0.82 (18) | 0.53 (28) | 0.34 (31) | 0.99 (25) | 23.25 | 27.00 | 25.50 |
26 | 0.46 (34) | 0.36 (31) | 0.35 (28) | 0.35 (34) | 0.27 (33) | 0.35 (31) | 0.86 (8) | 0.69 (13) | 0.39 (29) | 0.98 (29) | 26.25 | 26.25 | 24.25 |
27 | 0.61 (28) | 0.44 (29) | 0.27 (33) | 0.52 (32) | 0.38 (31) | 0.24 (32) | 0.81 (19) | 0.57 (22) | 0.35 (30) | 0.99 (27) | 26.50 | 27.00 | 27.00 |
28 | 0.57 (30) | 0.47 (26) | 0.48 (19) | 0.57 (29) | 0.53 (25) | 0.52 (20) | 0.57 (31) | 0.47 (30) | 0.49 (20) | 0.66 (31) | 30.25 | 28.25 | 22.50 |
29 | 0.55 (31) | 0.55 (23) | 0.47 (22) | 0.61 (28) | 0.60 (24) | 0.49 (25) | 0.51 (33) | 0.51 (29) | 0.49 (17) | 0.66 (32) | 31.00 | 26.75 | 24.25 |
30 | 0.70 (25) | 0.28 (33) | 0.33 (31) | 0.70 (25) | 0.46 (28) | 0.45 (27) | 0.75 (25) | 0.28 (33) | 0.34 (32) | 0.99 (26) | 25.25 | 30.25 | 28.00 |
31 | 0.57 (29) | 0.33 (32) | 0.28 (32) | 0.49 (33) | 0.31 (32) | 0.23 (33) | 0.82 (17) | 0.57 (21) | 0.44 (25) | 0.98 (28) | 26.75 | 28.50 | 28.50 |
32 | 0.52 (32) | 0.44 (28) | 0.46 (24) | 0.55 (31) | 0.52 (26) | 0.48 (26) | 0.52 (32) | 0.40 (31) | 0.45 (23) | 0.66 (33) | 32.00 | 29.50 | 26.25 |
33 | 0.49 (33) | 0.41 (30) | 0.42 (27) | 0.57 (30) | 0.45 (30) | 0.45 (28) | 0.44 (34) | 0.40 (32) | 0.44 (26) | 0.66 (34) | 32.75 | 31.50 | 28.75 |
34 | 0.69 (26) | 0.15 (34) | 0.00 (42) | 0.83 (18) | 0.18 (34) | 0.00 (42) | 0.61 (30) | 0.19 (34) | 0.00 (42) | 0.86 (30) | 26.00 | 33.00 | 39.00 |
35 | 0.14 (35) | 0.13 (35) | 0.11 (34) | 0.15 (35) | 0.16 (35) | 0.12 (34) | 0.12 (35) | 0.12 (35) | 0.11 (34) | 0.17 (35) | 35.00 | 35.00 | 34.25 |
36 | 0.11 (36) | 0.05 (36) | 0.03 (35) | 0.13 (36) | 0.05 (36) | 0.07 (35) | 0.10 (36) | 0.06 (37) | 0.03 (35) | 0.13 (36) | 36.00 | 36.25 | 35.25 |
37 | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (36) | 0.03 (39) | 0.03 (37) | 0.03 (36) | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (39) | 0.03 (37) | 0.03 (38) | 38.25 | 38.00 | 36.75 |
38 | 0.06 (37) | 0.03 (37) | 0.00 (42) | 0.06 (37) | 0.03 (40) | 0.00 (42) | 0.07 (37) | 0.08 (36) | 0.00 (42) | 0.10 (37) | 37.00 | 37.50 | 40.75 |
39 | 0.03 (41) | 0.03 (39) | 0.03 (37) | 0.03 (40) | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (43) | 0.03 (41) | 0.03 (36) | 0.03 (42) | 41.50 | 39.50 | 38.00 |
40 | 0.03 (40) | 0.03 (40) | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (41) | 0.03 (39) | 0.03 (39) | 0.03 (41) | 0.03 (40) | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (41) | 40.75 | 40.00 | 39.25 |
41 | 0.03 (39) | 0.03 (41) | 0.02 (39) | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (41) | 0.03 (37) | 0.03 (42) | 0.03 (42) | 0.02 (41) | 0.03 (40) | 39.75 | 41.75 | 39.25 |
42 | 0.03 (43) | 0.03 (42) | 0.02 (40) | 0.02 (43) | 0.03 (42) | 0.02 (40) | 0.03 (40) | 0.03 (43) | 0.03 (40) | 0.03 (43) | 42.25 | 42.25 | 40.75 |
43 | 0.02 (44) | 0.02 (43) | 0.01 (41) | 0.02 (44) | 0.01 (44) | 0.01 (41) | 0.03 (39) | 0.03 (38) | 0.03 (39) | 0.03 (44) | 42.75 | 42.50 | 41.25 |
44 | 0.03 (42) | 0.00 (44) | 0.00 (42) | 0.03 (42) | 0.01 (43) | 0.00 (42) | 0.03 (44) | 0.00 (44) | 0.00 (42) | 0.03 (39) | 41.75 | 42.50 | 42.75 |
45 | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (42) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (42) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (42) | 0.03 (45) | 45.00 | 44.75 | 41.25 |
46 | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (42) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (42) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (45) | 0.00 (42) | 0.00 (46) | 45.25 | 45.25 | 42.75 |
Position | Dice | Positive Predictive Value | Sensitivity | Kappa | Complete tumor Rank | Tumor core Rank | Enhancing tumor Rank | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
complete | core | enhancing | complete | core | enhancing | complete | core | enhancing | |||||
1 | 0.93 (1) | 0.95 (1) | 0.00 (1) | 0.88 (2) | 0.95 (1) | 0.00 (1) | 0.97 (3) | 0.95 (1) | 0.00 (1) | 1.00 (2) | 2.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
2 | 0.89 (3) | 0.90 (2) | 0.00 (1) | 0.82 (5) | 0.88 (2) | 0.00 (1) | 0.99 (1) | 0.93 (2) | 0.00 (1) | 1.00 (3) | 3.00 | 2.00 | 1.00 |
3 | 0.92 (2) | 0.87 (3) | 0.00 (1) | 0.87 (3) | 0.88 (3) | 0.00 (1) | 0.98 (2) | 0.90 (3) | 0.00 (1) | 1.00 (1) | 2.00 | 3.00 | 1.00 |
4 | 0.88 (4) | 0.82 (4) | 0.00 (1) | 0.82 (4) | 0.84 (4) | 0.00 (1) | 0.96 (4) | 0.84 (5) | 0.00 (1) | 1.00 (4) | 4.00 | 4.25 | 1.00 |
5 | 0.86 (5) | 0.78 (5) | 0.00 (1) | 0.89 (1) | 0.77 (5) | 0.00 (1) | 0.87 (6) | 0.84 (4) | 0.00 (1) | 1.00 (5) | 4.25 | 4.75 | 1.00 |
6 | 0.27 (6) | 0.12 (6) | 0.00 (1) | 0.20 (6) | 0.07 (6) | 0.00 (1) | 0.50 (7) | 0.41 (7) | 0.00 (1) | 0.98 (6) | 6.25 | 6.25 | 1.00 |
7 | 0.18 (7) | 0.07 (7) | 0.00 (1) | 0.11 (7) | 0.04 (7) | 0.00 (1) | 0.96 (5) | 0.45 (6) | 0.00 (1) | 0.91 (7) | 6.50 | 6.75 | 1.00 |
8 | 0.06 (8) | 0.05 (8) | 0.00 (1) | 0.06 (8) | 0.04 (8) | 0.00 (1) | 0.06 (8) | 0.06 (8) | 0.00 (1) | 0.08 (8) | 8.00 | 8.00 | 1.00 |